Create Your Own Pizza Creations
The Secret Menu

pizza with sausage and olives

June 25, 2020

At Casey’s we are proud to offer a pizza menu that has something to please everyone. For example, if you’re a huge meat lover, then our Meat Galore Specialty Pizza is for you! If you prefer something simple and cheesy – our Cheese Pizza has your name written all over it. We have so many delicious pizza choices in between, too. But did you know that if you browsed our menu and didn’t find that perfect pizza, you can even create your own custom pizza too? We have 17 different pizza toppings that you can mix-and-match for what seems like endless possibilities. If you need some custom pizza inspiration — here are five clever combinations some of our guests love – you might even call it our secret pizza menu!

Hawaiian Pizza

Create Your Own Pizza Creations

These are not official pizzas – choose Create Your Own Pizza when you order!

Margherita Pizza

Choose spinach and tomatoes to complement our hearty marinara sauce and gooey 100% mozzarella cheese. Try it on our flatbread crust to give your pizza a yummy crunch. Plus, add chicken if you want some extra protein!

Italian Grinder Pizza

Add sausage, onions, and banana peppers to turn a classic sandwich into a custom one-of-a-kind pizza that is sure to knock some socks off.

Hawaiian Pizza

Ham and pineapple — the perfect sweet and savory duo. (Add bacon if you want to take the flavor up a notch more)!

Spicy Trio Pizza

Pepperoni, hot sausage, and jalapeños. Can your taste buds handle this mouthwatering mix of flavors?

Stuffed Pepper Pizza

Beef, onions, and green peppers. Get the same stuffed-pepper taste you love, but without all the time and hard work!

These are just a few of the combinations you can create – did any of your build-your-own pizza favorites make the list? Or did you see any new combinations above that you’re dying to try?

sausage and jalapeno pizza

How to Order

So you’re probably wondering how to order one of these “secret menu” pizzas. Ordering a customized pizza is easy:

  1. Head over to our pizza menu
  2. Select Create Your Own Pizza
  3. Choose the size and crust type
  4. Add your favorite meat and veggie combination, and place your order
  5. Take a photo of your masterpiece and tag us on Facebook, Twitter, or Instagram with the hashtag #CaseysSecretMenu

Loading, please wait.